| Date | H/A | Opponents | Comp. | Res. | Scorers |
| 06/08/96 | H | Egham Town | BKMT | 1-1 | Unknown (won 5-3 on penalties) |
| 17/08/96 | A | Hartley Wintney | CCL | 5-0 | Holman 2, Cambridge, Jolly, German |
| 20/08/96 | A | Ash United | CCL | 1-1 | Jolly |
| 24/08/96 | H | Sandhurst Town | CCL | 2-4 | Jolly 2 |
| 26/08/96 | A | Cobham | CCL | 0-0 | |
| 31/08/96 | H | Slade Green | FACP | 2-0 | Holman, B. Jolly |
| 07/09/96 | H | Saltdean United | FAV1Q | 4-1 | German, Hill, Flurry, Holman |
| 14/09/96 | A | Dulwich Hamlet | FAC1Q | 0-2 | |
| 17/09/96 | H | Westfield | CCL | 2-1 | Hill, German |
| 21/09/96 | A | Raynes Park Vale | CCL | 3-2 | Edwards, German 2 |
| 24/09/96 | A | Chipstead | CCL | 0-0 | |
| 28/09/96 | H | Netherne | CCL | 2-0 | German, Hill |
| 01/10/96 | A | Raynes Park Vale | SCC1 | 7-1 | Holman 3, German, D. Smith, W Heggarty, Eggington |
| 05/10/96 | H | Crockenhill | FAV2Q | 4-0 | German, D. Smith, B. Jolly, Holman |
| 08/10/96 | H | Feltham | CCL | 4-0 | German 2 (1 pen) Jolly, Holman |
| 12/10/96 | A | Sandhurst Town | CCLC1 | 6-1 | Jolly 2, German, Holman, D. Smith, Bulman |
| 19/10/96 | A | Cranleigh | CCL | 3-0 | German 3 (1 pen) |
| 22/10/96 | H | Ruislip Manor | MCC2 | 2-1 | German, B. Jolly |
| 26/10/96 | H | Farnham Town | CCL | 5-0 | Flurry 3, German, McDonald |
| 29/10/96 | A | Woking | SSC1 | 0-3 | |
| 02/11/96 | H | Horsham | FAV1 | 1-0 | McDonald |
| 05/11/96 | H | Northwood | MSC1 | 1-3 | German |
| 09/11/96 | A | Corinthian-Casuals | CCL | 1-5 | German |
| 16/11/96 | H | Hartley Wintney | CCL | 3-0 | German, Selley, B. Jolly |
| 23/11/96 | H | Burnham | FAV2 | 0-1 | |
| 30/11/96 | H | Ash United | CCL | 4-2 | D. Smith 2, Edwards, Holman |
| 07/12/96 | A | Walton Casuals | CCL | 4-2 | German 3 (1 pen), Heggarty |
| 10/12/96 | A | Bedfont | CCLC2 | 0-0 aet | |
| 14/12/96 | H | Merstham | CCL | 2-0 | Holman, German |
| 21/12/96 | A | Merstham | CCL | 3-1 | German, Holman, McDonald |
| 28/12/96 | H | Bedfont | CCL | 3-4 | Flurry 2, German |
| 14/01/97 | H | Bedfont | CCLC2r | 1-0 aet * | Holman |
| 18/01/97 | H | Walton Casuals | CCL | 4-0 | German 2 (1 pen), McDonald, Cambridge |
| 25/01/97 | H | Chipstead | CCL | 2-0 | D. Smith (pen), McDonald |
| 01/02/97 | A | Sandhurst Town | CCL | 3-1 | German, Holman, D. Smith |
| 08/02/97 | H | Cove | CCL | 2-0 | o.g., German |
| 15/02/97 | A | Reading Town | CCL | 0-1 | |
| 18/02/97 | H | Cranleigh | CCL | 4-1 | German 2, D. Smith, McDonald |
| 22/02/97 | H | Godalming & Guildford | CCL | 0-1 | |
| 25/02/97 | A | Uxbridge | MCC3 | 2-1 | McDonald, Frost |
| 01/03/97 | A | Viking Sports | CCL | 3-0 | German, McDonald 2 |
| 08/03/97 | A | Farnham Town | CCL | 2-2 | McDonald, Cambridge |
| 15/03/97 | H | Raynes Park Vale | CCL | 3-1 | German (pen), Frost, Bulman |
| 18/03/97 | H | Viking Sports | CCL | 3-2 | Bulman 2, German |
| 22/03/97 | A | Westfield | CCL | 1-1 | D. Vertannes |
| 25/03/97 | H | Corinthian-Casuals | CCLC3 | 1-0 | Miles |
| 29/03/97 | A | Godalming & Guildford | CCL | 5-1 | German 2, I. Miles, Bulman, McDonald |
| 31/03/97 | H | Cobham | CCL | 3-1 | Silbery, Hollands, Jolly |
| 05/04/97 | H | Reading Town | CCL | 4-1 | Holman 3, Bulman |
| 08/04/97 | H | Epsom & Ewell | SCC2 | 5-2 | D. Vertannes 3, Holman, German |
| 12/04/97 | A | Godalming & Guildford | CCLCSF | 1-3 | Vertannes |
| 15/04/97 | A | Cove | CCL | 2-1 | German, Vertannes |
| 26/04/97 | A | Bedfont | CCL | 5-0 | German (pen), Vertannes, Bulman, McDonald, D. Smith |
| 29/04/97 | A | Wembley | MCCSF | 0-2 | |
| 03/05/97 | A | Netherne | CCL | 2-2 | McDonald, Hollands |
| 05/05/97 | A | Hampton | SCCSF | 0-2 | |
| 07/05/97 | A | Feltham | CCL | 8-1 | German 5, Heggarty, Frost, Jolly |
| 10/05/97 | H | Corinthian-Casuals | CCL | 4-0 | German 2, Frost 2 |
| * = match ordered to be replayed due to insufficient extra time being played | |||||